“They were coming at me with a knife. Extremely… slowly.”

Blargle Add comments

That scene in 2001: Space Odyssey as if it had been written by David Mamet. No, really. So wrong, and yet… so right.

Via Ace of Spades, of course. Oh yeah — because Arthur C. Clark is dead. I never read any of his stuff (too sciencey) but I did see 2001 finally a while back. Okay. Still, it was better than that freaking sequel, 2010: Space Criminey, or whatever the hell that was. You know how annoying and pretentious it is when a movie shows a scene of people shouting dialogue at each other that would normally (you know, in the real world, which science fiction and every other genre must reference for the rest of the nonsense to be believable) be simply stated in a regular tone of voice? Well, 2010 had several scenes like that. They were the high points of the movie, which also had that late-80s/early-90s cliché of the Cute Russian Character getting killed. Imagine if Star Trek had done that with Chekhov (for real, not for fake as in that one episode where aliens made the away team think they were fighting in the OK Corral), how that would have sucked. You know, because it was so hackneyed — “Aw, good-bye, cute Russian, we don’t really hate you, just your evil Commie government!” Anyway, 2001 was weird but at least made sense within its own goofy framework, whereas 2010 just sucked. Also it established — I’m sorry — that the late, great Roy Scheider’s main acting talent was a sort of prairie dog-like upright staring look, at least in movies where he didn’t have to keep up with gay jazz dancers.

2 Responses to ““They were coming at me with a knife. Extremely… slowly.””

  1. Fuloydo Says:

    I’ve got quite a bit of his fiction on my shelves. Most of it is a little too dry to be truly interesting to most people but there are a few exceptions.

    If you can find a copy, “A Fall of Moondust” is a wonderful read. Innocent people trapped by a freak accident; Rescue difficult if not impossible; Stalwart engineer works with prickly scientist to save the day. Not a lot of flash-zoom action in it but a lot of group dynamics driven plot.

  2. Fuloydo Says:

    Oh, and I totally agree with your sentiments on 2010 the movie. 2010 the book was excellent. Much better than 2001. Why the film makers felt the need to mess with the characters is beyond me.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.